Saturday, October 03, 2009

How the media reported on yesterday's meeting ...


... between HRD Minister Kapil Sibal and IIT FA representatives. I have used bold emphasis quite liberally.

The Economic Times:

The month-long impasse between IIT faculty and HRD ministry was resolved on Friday with minister Kapil Sibal offering a face saver to the protesting faculty.

Without rolling back guidelines set out in the September 16 notification, Mr Sibal has offered IITs 'flexibility' in interpreting the order. ...

The Times of India:

Without changing a word from the government's September 16 pay notification and by just using the word `flexibility', HRD minister Kapil Sibal on Friday assuaged the IIT faculty that has been protesting for nearly six weeks against the pay structure and autonomy.

DNA:

While Sibal agreed to "re-look" the contentious issue of promotions, including a 40% cap, to senior grade, he refused to concede their other demand for better pay. [...]

Ashok Jhunjhunwala of IIT-Chennai, however, said the minister said or offered nothing new. "Most demands were met earlier when our directors met the HRD minister. [... ] The teachers were looking for an escape route to wriggle out of this situation, which Sibal provided," he said.

The Hindu:

... Federation president M. Thenmozhi said [that] ... the Federation has been told that amendments would be made in the September 16 notification on pay revision of teachers in Centrally Funded Technical Institutions (CFTI) to remove minor irritants.

In which I learn about emoticons for sarcasm ...


Giridhar says I should have relied on something more than "Ah, this victory must smell so sweet!" to convey how hollow I thought IIT FAs' "victory" was.

Evidently, the "Ah" at the beginning just doesn't cut it as a verbal marker for irony / sarcasm / snark. The comments indicate that several people just took the outcome of yesterday's meeting as a real victory for the IIT FAs. Perhaps they have other, independent evidence to think that way, but I certainly think of it as a hollow victory devoid of any real, substantive concessions.

In addition to being nebulous, autonomy and flexibility are also so cheap that they could be dished out during the course of a broadcast interview!

* * *

I have received three pieces of advice on how to avoid that kind of blogging FAIL:

  1. Just use plain language to convey what you feel.

  2. Use explicit markers (something like [snark] ... [/snark]).

  3. Use emoticons such as :d or :-J. (This is from Giridhar).

Friday, October 02, 2009

Fairness in SPC pay hikes for university and college teachers


A month ago, I asked how fair the SPC pay hikes have been at IIXs and universities. I tried to answer this question by looking at the ratio of the 'raw' salaries in December 2005 (before SPC) and in January 2006 (after SPC).

At IIXs, the pay hikes are roughly the same at all levels -- right from assistant professors all the way up to full professors (let's leave OCAPs for the moment, as they have just been created).

However, this is not so for the faculty in our universities: while pay hikes for professors are in line with those at IIXs, they are far lower for the lecturers and readers. [see that post for the details].

This led me to conclude that, if anything, it is the university folks -- especially the junior faculty -- that had a greater right to go on strike over the SPC implementation. But we never saw our university faculty rising up in protest! Why?

We have an answer now. Over at Kafila, Sunalini Kumar discusses the politics of SPC pay hikes, and what they mean for junior faculty in our universities and colleges. There's a lot in that post, but let me excerpt the key section on the divide between junior and senior faculty [with bold emphasis added by me]:

... he recent Pay Commission has greatly redressed the issue of pay, a fact that has been repeated ad nauseum in the media, but the little known fact is that the substantially higher pay applies only to senior faculty (those who in government parlance are called Pay Band 4), whereas younger faculty in Pay Band 3 have seen only a marginal increase in pay. More disturbingly, the arbitrary and punitive service conditions introduced by the UGC make promotions dependent on acquiring a certain number of points in your career, which in turn are dependent on conditions that are for the most part only very remotely concerned with college teaching and academics, and more importantly, nearly impossible for the average college teacher in India to fulfill. Explaining the full contours of this awful new monster the UGC has created, and what it will do to a profession I love more than anything in the world will require a full-length post in itself.

The main point here is, as far as the government is concerned, the combination of the sudden yawning gap between Pay Band 3 and 4, and the new service conditions together add up to a political and financial masterstroke. By giving a huge bonanza to Pay Band 4, the government has ensured their full support and acquiescence, and created a difference of interests between them and younger faculty. This was important from the government’s point of view, since it is the senior faculty who have been the most vociferous in the teachers movement, given their greater bargaining power and experience. Not surprisingly, they have dominated teachers’ unions in order to unanimously agree to the new pay package offered this time. As for service conditions regarding promotion especially, most Pay Band 4 teachers are past their final promotion, and many near retirement. So it is difficult to imagine that they would be unduly concerned; so effectively, those affected by the new service conditions are new and younger teachers in Pay band 3. The younger teachers have always been more vulnerable; most have taught as ad hoc or temporary faculty for many years, a humilating and debilitating experience…more so if one is in a state university, where contractual employment is very common. They will be rendered even more vulnerable and fragmented by these new conditions (one of whose principal effects will be to pitch individual teacher against individual teacher in order to acquire points for promotion). Hence, they will find it difficult if not impossible to mobilise themselves politically in unions to oppose any unjust moves by the government. The long term calculation of the government seems to be this – get rid of the political threat represented by the older faculty by giving them more than they expect, then bring in near-impossible conditions for promotion, so that very few of those currently in Pay Band 3 make it to Pay Band 4, ensuring that the loss of revenue incurred in the dramatically increased salary of Pay Band 4 will be more than offset in coming years with these older faculty retiring, and most of the younger faculty languishing at Pay Band 3 for the remainder of their careers.

However, none of these facts will ever make it to the front pages or the television scenes. Because, hidden beneath upper class and middle class notions about teaching as a noble profession and of ‘becoming behaviour’ and so on is scant understanding of the real reasons for the rot in education in this country and barely concealed contempt for college and university teachers. [...]

There you have it: the faculty unions' most vociferous members -- senior faculty -- shortchanged the interests of their junior colleagues.

* * *

I once ranted about resource-hogging senior faculty in our elite institutions -- basically, IIXs. If the situation is bad in IIXs, it's far worse in our universities, where senior faculty also enjoy enormous power over their junior colleagues.

Thus, Sunalini Kumar's version of events doesn't surprise me at all.

HRD Minister says IIT-HRD stand-off is resolved


Here's the report:

The guidelines issued on pay structure are only norms, he said, adding that the "IIT system has the flexibility to deviate from the norms in exceptional cases. We are prepared to re-visit any of the guideline in case of exceptional cases."

and

"If in a particular discipline faculty is not available as per the existing norms, the IITs can relax the norms to absorb any person," Sibal said.

In another report, Sibal invokes Gandhi Jayanti:

“On Gandhi Jayanti, I want to give good news to the nation. Now, there is no issue between the government and the IITs," Mr Sibal said after an hour-long meeting with IITs faculty federation here. Though there will be no change in the salary structure of the IIT faculty, the government is flexible on certain issues where there is a need for exception.

So, how did the IIT FA reps react?

Prof M Thenmozhi, President of All India IIT Faculty Federation, said they were happy with the discussions with Sibal. "The Minister has assured us about IIT retaining flexibility and they can relax norms. This will help IITs move forward," she said. [source]

Ah, this victory must smell so sweet! I can almost hear the popping of champagne corks from Guwahati to Mumbai, from Ropar to Chennai.

I wonder what they do at Gandhinagar to celebrate ;-)

NCERT textbooks


They are absolutely amazing compared to the books we got from the Tamil Nadu Board way back in the 1970s [BTW, the TNB books -- available for free download -- have also improved, but are not as great as those from NCERT].

Anahita Mukherji and Akshaya Mukul of ToI have a great report on some of the nifty things NCERT has done in its textbooks. Though students' preferences still depend a great deal on how good the teachers are, it's wonderful to see a child react to her text book like this:

... Ankita Kamath, a class VI student, says math is now her favourite subject. She loves studying the elementary shapes in geometry. "The textbook has lots of interesting exercises that we can do ourselves," she says. "We don't need to go for tuitions anymore."

Mukherjee and Mukul do a very good job of telling the NCERT story. Go read all of it.

* * *

FWIW, here's a previous post on how NCERT textbooks handle the issue of reservations.

IIT FAs' reps to meet HRD Minister today


There's some advance information about what the minister is likely to concede: not much. See the stories in The Telegraph and Indian Express. But the Times of India is a little more blunt: "Sibal won't oblige [IIT] faculty." So there.

The only real concession is on the 10 percent floor on OCAPs; it is now likely to be called an "advisory" provision, and not a mandatory one.

The 40 percent cap on senior professorship, the IITs are going to be asked to go to the IIT Council when they hit that ceiling, and ask for more. That's autonomy for you.

* * *

This, on the other hand, cracked me up:

“This meeting is in response to the IIT faculty’s telegram seeking an appointment with the minister. ...,” said a ministry official [source; Bold emphasis is not in the original].

Thursday, October 01, 2009

Links ...


  1. Michael Fitzgerald in The University of Chicago Magazine: Chicago Schooled. "The visible hand of the recession has revitalized critics of the Chicago School of Economics."

  2. Germaine Greer in The Guardian: Women everywhere -- please send a picture of your unsupported breasts to Stephen Bayley.

  3. Scott Jaschik in Inside Higher Ed: Next Stages in the Debate on Standardized Testing.

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

When you thought this government couldn't stoop any lower ...


... you get this truly vicious assault -- no, make that a murderous attack -- on academics' autonomy.

It's high time we started a massive campaign against these academic tormentors.

How about a Facebook group? Maybe we can call it Faculty Contra UGC Kooks (with due apologies to a dyslexic fashion brand)...

Manu Rajan: Perils of Elitism


Yet another opinion piece on higher education and faculty salaries. This one, by Manu Rajan in The New Indian Express, questions IIX faculty's demands for higher pay for yet another reason:

The recent demand by the faculty of the government-funded Indian Institute of Science and the Indian Institutes of Technology for superior pay and promotion policies, as compared to their counterparts in other universities, makes one wonder whether this degree of indulgence is proportional to the reputation an institute enjoys. Are pockets of ‘elite’ centres of learning necessarily a good idea, particularly when it is difficult to monitor their efficiency? [...]

Good teachers are scattered all across the country: scour the many government and private colleges and it is not difficult to find excellent teachers dedicated to their work. Many of our less endowed colleges could do better if they were able to avail the resources confined to the elite institutes. Is it not odd that while we talk of ‘open universities’, we are not ready to shed our love for the closed -access elite institutes housing a few privileged people who, already more advantaged, consider it their divine right to ask for even more?

Instead of hankering after ‘high rankings’ based on dubious quantitative measures for a handful of our elite institutes, the cause of India’s higher education would be better served through a fair and equitable access to research and learning resources. This, rather than the elitist approach, is more likely to lead us to producing Nobel Prize winners one day.

Pulapre Balakrishnan: Pay and Autonomy in the IITs


Here's his opinion piece in MInt. He's sympathetic to the demands for more autonomy, but raises questions about the pay hike demands on two different grounds:

We may query the demand for higher pay on two grounds. First, it is not clear that the principle that engineering faculty should earn more than the rest in the public educational sector is a sound one. Is it commonly agreed upon in India that engineering is superior to philosophy? As a principle this would be hard to find applied in the great universities of the world.

The privileging of engineering in India is the direct legacy of the plan for rapid industrialization of the country in the 1950s when the IITs were formed. Engineering education was the natural beneficiary. With hindsight, we can say that it would have been entirely possible at that stage to increase the number of engineers without hiving off the engineering college and paying its faculty more. Instead, India chose a strategy which resulted in a tiering of its public educational system, placing the IITs on top. Therefore, the demand by the IIT faculty for preserving this salary differential is not surprising, but that does not make it justifiable.

The claim that they have had to work harder to get there is untenable. The faculty of the Delhi School of Economics in the late 1960s combined the finest international qualifications with the highest class of research. Amartya Sen went on to win a Nobel Prize for work initiated there. Secondly, IIT faculty representatives have claimed a higher salary on the ground that this would mimic the industry standard for engineers. However, market signals are not always available to guide public sector pricing. Consider defence, which is publicly provided. We can now only guess at what its market value would be, and have to use other means to arrive at a reasonable salary for our jawans.

Subir Roy on an "alternative model" of governance at IITs


Subir Roy thinks he has figured out our academic system -- especially the IITs. He presents what he calls an "alternative model" for governance:

For every leading educational institution of excellence the government appoints a board of governors of eminent people who then supervise its running, including selecting its chief executive, according to a charter which comes with substantial public funds. There is a periodic charter review and it can be withdrawn for non-fulfilment but absolutely no micro-management. The charter contains guidelines on ceiling on tuition fee (these are leading institutions and so can charge a bomb and get away with it), norms for sharing the fruits of successfully commercialised research between government, institution and the relevant faculty, and provisions to ensure that successful consultants among the faculty have some time left to teach or guide researchers. The governors can pay the faculty the moon so long as the resources are there and certain outcomes, like number of patents secured and academic papers published, are met. The institution can make money out of executive development programmes and the governors can actively canvass philanthropists.

The government can replace governors as and when they reach 70 or 75, or better still, the board of governors can be self-perpetuating. They can find their replacements as vacancies occur. And public accountability can be maintained by keeping these institutions under the three Cs — CAG, CVC and CBI. Eminent people should engage Sibal in a public discourse and urge him to take a variation or improvement of the above to the cabinet for approval.

Wait a minute! Isn't this roughly what we have in the IITs (and IIXs in general)? Sure, they cannot "pay the moon" to their high fliers, but that restriction applies only to government money. They certainly can pay the moon to the high fliers from the money they generate through private sources -- alumni and other philanthropic donations, grants from industry, overheads on consultancy work, etc. This is also how IIT-K has established endowed chairs for some of their senior faculty.

Perhaps Subir Roy should really look at the governance structure at the IITs and tell us where he thinks it differs from his "alternative model," and why he thinks the IIT model falls short. I have written to him asking him precisely these questions. Let's see if we get a response.

Debate about whether professors at IITs and IIMs are underpaid


Business Standard presents two views. The first is from Gautam Ahuja (Ross School of Business, UMichigan). While he presents a comparison which makes IIM salaries look bad, he also makes the point that the "performance parameters" ... "are a lot less stringent" in India.

A fresh assistant professor joining a top-25 US business school would receive a pre-tax salary of about $135,000-$170,000 (Rs 67-85 lakh) plus pension and healthcare — there is no subsidised housing. There are variations within this: Finance faculty are paid more and private schools will pay on the higher end of this band. Against this, the faculty are generally expected to teach 100-150 hours per academic year. They are, however, expected to publish in the top-tier academic journals which have very high rejection rates — failure to meet these publishing standards usually implies that once your probationary period of 5-7 years is over, you are forced to leave the institution (a fairly common occurrence at the top schools). [Bold emphasis added]

The second participant in the debate is Dinesh Mohan (IIT-D):

As for comparisons with overseas engineering institutes, it’s not as though a teacher in a western university is paid industrial salaries. Most American or European elite universities, public or private, pay public-sector salaries prevailing in each country to their engineering faculty. We should also not be comparing our salaries with a few BTechs or MBAs who get high-paying jobs. We can compare our salaries only with fresh PhDs in engineering who get a permanent research job including housing. Then we’ll find that we are not so badly off.

Ashok Jhunjhunwala on autonomy in IITs


In an interview by Mint's Aparna Kalra, Jhunjhunwala, one of the more prominent professors at IIT-M, says this about the issue of institutional autonomy:

I have had plenty of conversations with IIT directors. In some issues, government has acted Big Brother with us—in terms of increasing number of students (because of reservations) we were not given much choice. There is some very loose kind of thing on faculty reservations. There are some national-level policy issues on which government will have a say.

I don’t think beyond this government tells IITs anything.

I really think there is significant amount of autonomy. Government gives us money, we have to have salary structure in tune with government pay. MHRD (ministry of human resource development) gives each IIT Rs120-180 crore per year. Compared to the money we get, interference is negligible. How they are run, what is the promotion policy, things are fairly flexible.

To a question about whether IITs can ever become financially independent (like IIMs have done):

I don’t think so. I have tried to work it out in terms of fees. Some of the alumni talk big, but no IIT has been able to create that kind of corpus. Unless you are ready to charge Rs5-6 lakh per student in which case there will be a lot of problem. I don’t mind moving in that direction, but it is going to be tough. People are not used to taking this loan and then paying heavily.

We can charge this fees only to undergraduates. Even with this fees, (we will) not even come close to one-third of our budget.

And then there's this section where he lists the (hidden) benefits of working in an IIT:

IIT Madras has a beautiful campus, where I have free housing. There is a hospital, which my family can use. There are two schools. My children can go to these schools. Maintainance of the house is free. Five days a month I can build consultancy capability. I am allowed to go on boards of companies and retain board fees. For 60 days a year, I can go abroad on a fellowship. After six years, I can go for a sabbatical for a year, three times in my career. Of course, we have to excel. Industry will give us consultancy only if we excel.

That autonomy is very precious to us. Nobody can force us to do anything.

Monday, September 28, 2009

You guys are precious. You deserve everything you have asked for ...


Watch Karan Thapar's Devil's Advocate interview of HRD Minister Kapil Sibal (or, read the transcript), where the minister is reported to have made several 'concessions'.

Without realizing what the 'concessions' mean, Thapar sounds very satisfied about his batting on behalf of IIT faculty. He has every right to be, I suppose; after all, he gets to condescend to the minister for the latter's "mature" responses in the interview! [You won't find that in the transcript, but watch Part 3 of the interview.]

You can read the interview to see for yourself how much the 'concessions' are really worth. I'll stick to what I think is the most important issue: OCAP. In the excerpt below, note how this issue has been framed as one of "10% minimum" (and hence, as something that intrudes into institutional autonomy), but not as a terrible deal -- for both individuals and institutions.

Karan Thapar: Let's then, to clarify the situation, go through the principal demands of the IIT faculty one by one so that you can explain what is your actual response to it.

To begin with, the IITs are a little perplexed, or perhaps I should put it a little strongly, concerned with your recent stipulation that at least 10 per cent of the entries into faculty should be by way of contracts. Let me begin by asking you, what's the purpose of this?

Kapil Sibal: The purpose is that normally, or rather that is a norm that when it is a person with a PhD without industrial, teaching or research experience (joins the IIT as faculty), he/she should be on a contract. But on a regular position, not ad-hoc.

On contract, if at the end of three years, the IIT people and the board feel that he should be absorbed, then he should be absorbed. However, this is the norm. If however in the course of these three years, the IIT Board or the Director recommends to the board that look, this man is outstanding; let's even waive the three year period, we would not interfere in that.

Karan Thapar: You said something really important. You are saying that although the 10 per cent requirement to the new entrants to the faculty that are to be taken on contract is the norm; and that the norm is designed to make sure that you get the best of people and not left out strata of people you do not want. Nonetheless, you have said to me that exceptional people at the discretion of IIT directors can be taken, on tenure from the outside.

Kapil Sibal: Absolutely, yes. Not only exceptional people, but people who have been taken on three-year-contract and who expect to be absorbed after three years; even their term can be reduced when the IIT Board says that look, here's a man who is exceptional, so let us waive the three-years (norm).

While I leave you to think about whether this is the victory you really wanted, let me put in my bits of snark. It's good to get the anger out of one's system ...

When you invent "autonomy" as a organizing theme for your protest action (just three days before the said action), you deserve anti-concessions, that actually raise the bar for you -- "Sure, we would love it if you waive the post-doc requirement for a C.N.R. Rao or a Stephen Hawking! [Implication: anyone less deserves just an OCAP]

When you use autonomy as a respectable cover for your piffling grievances, you deserve only meaningless platitudes on autonomy -- and nothing about your grievances.

When you sell autonomy-coated scrap metal as designer jewellery, you deserve sugar-coated non-concessions -- "IITs are precious!" and "IIT councils always had autonomy! Why would we mess with that?"

* * *

I became concerned (and very upset) when pay hike demands were hijacked by a silly debate on autonomy because I feared that the OCAP issue would be de-emphasized and misrepresented.

I can only hope I'm wrong in my assessment that these fears may just have come true.

Sunday, September 27, 2009

Links ...


  1. Pam Belluck: A burst of technology, helping the blind to see. Some pretty amazing stuff here. Here's one:

    Sharron Kay Thornton, 60, from Smithdale, Miss., blinded by a skin condition, regained sight in one eye after doctors at the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine extracted a tooth (her eyetooth, actually), shaved it down and used it as a base for a plastic lens replacing her cornea.

    It was the first time the procedure, modified osteo-odonto-keratoprosthesis, was performed in this country. The surgeon, Dr. Victor L. Perez, said it could help people with severely scarred corneas from chemical or combat injuries.

  2. The Situationist Blog: Change Blindness (a video explaining a very intriguing form of attentional blindness).

  3. Richard Thaler (of Nudge fame): Opting in vs. opting out (how to nudge people to agree to donate their organs).

  4. Giridhar offers a balanced take on the IIX salaries. Along the way, you will also learn more about what exactly will be the salary of a freshly minted assistant professor. His concern, which I share, is about how to make IIXs friendly places for junior faculty.

  5. Tarek El-Tablawy: Saudi Arabia launches KAUST, a grand science and technology university.