Wednesday, August 10, 2005

More professional mixups

I posted a while ago about some of the interesting responses from people when they are introduced to anthropologists.

Commenters are having a riot on this post at Cosmic Variance and this one at Brian Weatherson's site. The topic? Strangers' responses when they meet physicists and philosophers, respectively.

This one by a commenter named 'Barry' is a jem:

Five or so years ago I was on a panel of prospective jurors being questioned by an attorney for the defendant:

Attorney: What is your profession?

Me: I am a philosopher

Attorney: Philosophy? Is that a "helping profession"

Me: Its more like a helpless profession

Judge (laughing): This is no place for jokes..your out.

My all time favourite story, however, was from Alex Tabarrok. The conversation is between Tabarrok and his masseuse:

"Has anyone told you that you are great today? I can tell that you have a lot of loving energy. You're a very giving person."

"Wow," I replied, "no one has ever said that. I'm an economist."

"Oh," she replied, pausing slightly, "I guess I was wrong."

2 comments:

  1. I wonder if you have had any such encounters yourself! ;)

    I once met a chap at a social function. He turned out to an HR Manager and led an astounding assault against software programmers. I just agreed with him, as little that he said was wrong anyway. Just had the presence of mind to not tell him my true profession!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well, Kiran, I studied metallurgy, so the story I recounted at the beginning of this post made an impression on me.

    ReplyDelete

Would you like to comment on this post (or, in response to one of the comments)? If so, please note:

1. This blog does not allow anonymous comments (any more), so please use an open-id account to comment.

2. Comments on posts older than 15 days go into a moderation queue, and may take some time to appear.

Thank you for joining the conversation. Have your say: