Monday, June 19, 2006

Diversity in newsroom


After this and this from India, we have two interesting reports.

The first one is from the US (link via Pradeepkumar):

...[The] percentage of minorities working in newsrooms crept up from 13.42 to 13.87 percent.

Though newspapers are increasing their hiring and retention of minority journalists, newsroom diversity is falling behind the nation’s rapidly changing demographics. A third of the U.S. population is now minority, according to the latest estimates from the U.S. Census Bureau.

There's a lot of data available from the same organization; they can be accessed from this page.

The second is from the UK. Hasan Suroor writes in today's op-ed in the Hindu:

[Sutton Trust's] research, released last week, shows that a whopping 54 per cent of Britain's top newspaper and television journalists — editors, columnists, anchors, executives — were educated at expensive private schools, which cater for only seven per cent of all school-going children in the country. Thirty-three per cent came from grammar schools where admission is based on selection, and only 14 per cent from state-funded comprehensives that 90 per cent of the country's children attend.

Among the journalists who went to university, nearly half the top brass went to Oxford or Cambridge.

Sunday, June 18, 2006

Preventing fraud in news reporting


Byron Calame, Public Editor at the NYTimes, has a column on the changes implemented in the Times' newsroom that would have nipped the Jason Blair scandal in the bud:

The first is a simple procedure with far-reaching impact: The standards editor conducts weekly random checks of articles containing anonymous sourcing to make sure that an editor knows the name of the source. Let's assume Mr. Blair had been forced to tell an editor the name of each anonymous source he relied on in a December 2002 article that listed evidence pointing to young Lee Malvo as the primary triggerman in the Washington sniper case. The random checks could have given the editors a much better chance to detect that two pieces of evidence didn't exist — as The Times noted in a subsequent correction.

Planning and funding India's infrastructure


Montek Singh Ahluwalia, Deputy Chairman of Planning Commission and "the most prominent non-politician liberaliser in the government", gives his views in this Outlook interview:

From the point of view of the government, the critical issue, no doubt, is that of generating resources. Where is the money needed to create this higher level of infrastructure going to come from, FDI?

Resources can be raised in a number of ways. It can come in as foreign direct investment (FDI) or from domestic savings or even through market borrowings. The name of the game is not to focus on FDI but rather to create a policy framework that attracts investment. I do not have any sectoral targets of FDI for the country. If we have the right environment, all the domestic investment can get sucked into infrastructure, which will vacate space for foreign investments in other sectors. And if domestic investments go to other sectors, it will make space for FDI in infrastructure. Hence, we need two kinds of policies: the general policies that will make India an attractive destination for investment and another, more specific, one for infrastructure.

Wars ...


... of the Programming Language kind:

The remarkably wide range of programming languages would seem to offer something for everyone. We could celebrate diversity. We could let a thousand flowers bloom. What actually happens, more often, is that we launch a crusade to convert the infidels—or else exterminate them.

In 1975 Edsger W. Dijkstra, a major figure in the structured-programming movement, wrote a memo titled "How Do We Tell Truths that Might Hurt?" The "truths" were mostly Dijkstra's opinions of programming languages; how he told them was very bluntly. Fortran is "an infantile disorder," PL/I "a fatal disease," APL "a mistake, carried through to perfection." Students exposed to COBOL "are mentally mutilated beyond hope of regeneration," he said. "The use of COBOL cripples the mind; its teaching should, therefore, be regarded as a criminal offense." When the memo was published a few years later, defenders of COBOL and BASIC replied in kind, although none of them were quite able to match Dijkstra's acid rhetoric.

Handy tips for effective cheating


Alex Halavais offers some useful tips on cheating (via Savage Minds):

I would prefer that students don’t cheat. Yes, they really are mostly cheating themselves, so fine. But it also reflects poorly on the community. Rationally or not, what particularly irks me is that it is disrespectful: of me, of their fellow students, of the university, of the institution of learning, and of themselves. And—did I mention—of me? It is particularly irksome when their cheating implies (reminds?) that I am a fool.

So, to help students across the country cheat better, saving themselves both from easy detection and from incurring the wrath of insulted faculty, and leading to a much more harmonious school environment, I offer the following tips, based on recent experience.

Here's one of the tips:

7. Borrow from someone who writes as badly as you do.

Don’t do what one of my graduate students did, and steal a text on Korean feminism from someone who wrote slightly better English than he did. I’ll notice the slightly better writing, even before I notice that you have expressed no interest in or knowledge of feminist perspectives in the past. (Once kicked out of our program, he applied to the English department. No kidding.)

Over at Savage Minds (from where I got the link to Halavais' post), Oneman recounts this incident:

Last semester I had my crowning glory as a catcher of plagiarism. I’m reading this paper, and it’s so good, I’m stunned. I feel so proud; I’m actually thinking “wow, this student gets me!” At the risk of sounding immodest, the paper was so good and so spot-on about what anthropology is all about that it was like I had written it myself.

Of course I had written it myself—it came straight off of my Intro website. Not only was it plagiarism, but a violation of my Creative Commons “Attribution-Non-Commercial-Share-Alike” license—no attribution!

A different kind of overdose


An anonymous commenter chides me (here) for the "overdose of merit and reservations" on this blog. So, let me see if I can spend one full day without blogging about these issues. Let me start with a bunch of links to discussions of human sexuality by academics.

Mind Hacks:

The study found that erotic images differently activated the mid part of the female prefrontal cortex (the red area in the image on the left) when compared to other images, within 185ms. Interestingly, this was regardless of how arousing or emotionally strong the images were.

185ms is an incredibly short time for the brain to differentiate between image types, and is almost certainly an automatic response. The prefrontal cortex is known to be involved in attention, and the authors suggest this activity reflects a vigiliance for socially relevant visual scenes.

Pure Pedantry links to a study that found:

The results of the study are striking. As the women were stimulated, activity rose in one sensory part of the brain, called the primary somatosensory cortex, but fell in the amygdala and hippocampus, areas involved in alertness and anxiety. During orgasm, activity fell in many more areas of the brain, including the prefrontal cortex, compared with the resting state [...]

Cognitive Daily, inspired by the movie Bride and Prejudice, goes hunting for comparative studies:

Since arranged marriages and the values that surround them are still common in Korea, Jungsik Kim and Elaine Hatfield decided to survey American and Korean students about their attitudes about these two types of love and their relative levels of happiness. Like love, happiness can be divided into two types: life satisfaction (long-term), and positive emotions (short-term). [...]

And, finally, on this Father's day, Tyler Cowen re-posts an earlier post (by the Marginal Revolution guest blogger Robin Hanson) on "why many women prefer to be courted by cads" [as opposed to dads], a topic that brings out, in the comments section, all kinds of 'theories' to explain this 'phenomenon':

A standard story says that women like cads for short term relationships, to get good sex (i.e., genes), and dads for long term relationships, to get security and comfort (i.e., resources to raise kids). Of course some men are good in both roles, but most men are thought to be better at one role than the other.

Saturday, June 17, 2006

Veerappa Moily, the management guru


Though you maintain that the task ahead is possible, you concede that it is onerous. What are the greatest hurdles?

Mindset. We refuse to think out of the box. Revolutionary thinking will have to be introduced. Nothing is impossible in these days of technology. Once the mindset is liberated, we will be on our way.

Six management cliches in just a few lines; it just can't get better than this! Do read this interview of M. Veerappa Moily, Chairman of the Oversight Committee for implementation of 27 per cent reservation for OBCs in central educational institutions.

He mouthed "knowledge society" eight times in that interview; the politician in him made his presence felt through the use of the word "inclusive" -- twice.

Not in our backyard, and not now


A group called PanIIT Alumni Association, claiming to represent "approximately 150,000 alumni of the seven IITs worldwide", has written a letter to the President of India and the Prime Minister (among others) about the proposed OBC quotas. After the preamble, the letter states the following right at the outset:

The PanIIT alumni organizations, are strongly supportive of affirmative action and creating equal opportunity for all. [...]

After making this refreshing admission of its support for affirmative action, the group goes on to pour bucket-fuls of cold water on the OBC quota proposal. In the second part of the letter, it restates its commitment:

The PanIIT Alumni association is united in its commitment to the need to work with underprivileged groups. We will bring the resources of our association to work with the government to help implement programs that achieve the goals of social reform.

The group follows this up with some of its ideas about how "the goals of social reform" can be achieved. What are these ideas?

a. Increased access to primary and secondary education in backward areas: This action will create opportunities for people from all classes from backward areas to be better prepared for the Joint Entrance Examination to the IITs. Such focused schools may adopt a process for identifying �gifted and talented� students for special education, and consider having them participate in summer programs at IITs.

b. Creation of institutions similar to the IITs but focused on vocational education, and highly-skilled workers: We see a big gap between the IITs and India�s ability to produce good technicians. We recommend the creation of institutions similar to the IITs but focused on vocational education, and highly skilled workers. As India encourages the growth of the manufacturing sector, we believe the demand for such services will greatly increase and, thus, offer new economic opportunities.

c. Implementing programs at IITs for regular and after-hours classes: Post- graduate students should be encouraged thru Teaching Fellowships to teach tutorial classes and after�hours programs that are designed for SC/ST/OBC students who are competent but unable to compete effectively in the JEE. Distance learning classes using Edusat and the internet should be adopted for offering preparatory tutorials to enable such students become fully capable to compete in JEE.

d. All course work from the IITs should be made available for free on the Internet: Such a program would give unrestricted access to all individuals who want to follow the daily classroom lectures at the IITs, greatly expanding the reach of the existing facilities. Students who follow this program may be able to supplement their Internet-based education through private or public institutions leading to an Associates Degree, recognized by the IITs.

Well, there you have it. That's the PanIIT Alumni Association's agenda for social reform.

* * *

I want to restrict myself to just three comments.

First, if you read the letter, you will realize that the group's grouse (I don't think all the IIT alumni share this group's views, notwithstanding its grand claim that it represents "approximately 150,000 alumni of the seven IITs worldwide") is not just with the proposed OBC quotas; not-so-well-hidden in the letter is the message that the group is against all quotas -- including the existing SC/ST quotas.

Second, the group continues to swear by the sanctity of the Joint Entrance Examination. Remember, this is an exam that "getting increasingly closer to the syllabus of science graduate programmes, making aspirants more and more dependent on coaching classes", and hence has an in-built bias against the poor and rural students (more on this in an earlier post). Finally, this is an exam that's so exquisitely designed that it manages to bring in a nearly all-male student body (in spite of the fact that women do about as well as men in their high school exams). Clearly, PanIIT AA doesn't believe that JEE might need to be re-jigged, or that IITs need a re-examine their JEE-centric admissions policy.

Finally, just read PanIIT AA's second idea ("Creation of institutions similar to the IITs but focused on vocational education, and highly-skilled workers"). It's one thing to propose such an idea in the broader context of education reforms in India; but, it's an entirely different thing -- with seriously nasty connotations -- when this proposal is made as one of the alternatives to quotas for OBCs.

Cash incentives for academic publications?


Nature, a leading science journal, doesn't like the idea [link via Pradeepkumar]. The immediate provocation is the plan by South Korea to introduce such awards. Here's the relevant quote from its editorial:

But there are some powerful arguments against the widespread adoption of the practice. Cash bonuses tied to specific publications are likely to exacerbate corrupting tendencies in the scientific community. Debates over who should be included on author lists, and who should be the first author and the corresponding author, will surely get even more vicious when a chunk of money is on the line. A scientist struggling to meet a mortgage payment might be more willing to forgo a potentially fantastic result for a quick cash-earner. And a researcher measuring science in terms of dollars might even be more tempted to plagiarize or fabricate data.

All this is quite sensible; but, it's important to keep in mind that publications in high impact journals lead to many other rewards: better chance of funding for your future projects, awards and recognition (some of which come with cash prizes), and early promotion (with its built-in cash incentive). Thus, an explicit award for each publication just happens to extend this trend (which, by the way, is quite common in industry, where cash incentives are given for patents, and sometimes, also for papers). So, I don't see any great reason to get worked up about it; I mean, I don't see any important principle at stake here.

I want to highlight something else in the editorial. This sentence (which appears just after the above quote) betrays a shady motive:

In countries recently damaged by high-profile cases of scientific corruption, where it is all the more essential to develop a culture of integrity, the award of large sums of money for high-impact publications is even less desirable.

This is an ugly, gratuitous attack on the integrity of thousands of sincere and honest scientists in South Korea. We must remember that the Hwang Woo Suk scandal was unearthed by an army of junior researchers in South Korea itself; they don't need this sanctimonious lecture about integrity from the editorial high offices of Nature which, together with its high impact counterparts elsewhere, should be examining their own not-so-stellar role in such scandals.

Friday, June 16, 2006

Pratap Bhanu Mehta: Unshackle the higher ed system


The Indian education system is one of the most tightly controlled in the world. The government regulates who you can teach, what you can teach them and what you can charge them. It also has huge regulatory bottlenecks. There are considerable entry barriers: Universities can be set up only through acts of legislation, approval procedures for starting new courses are cumbersome, syllabi revision is slow, and accreditation systems are extremely weak and arbitrary. The regulators permit relatively little autonomy for institutions and variation amongst them.

Over-regulation has produced the crisis of higher education that is the context of the current agitation. The shortage of quality institutions is a product of India’s regulatory structures. Increased public investment that the government has promised is absolutely necessary to increase access. But this investment will not yield much if India’s regulatory regime remains rigid.

From this YaleGlobal article by Pratap Bhanu Mehta.

I sincerly wish Mehta hadn't pushed the National Knowledge Commission into taking a stand on the quota issue. It's a pity that, in the ugly aftermath, he has had to resign his Membership of the NKC; his excellent ideas on how to design and implement a superior higher ed system in India could have formed the right framework for the Commission to build on.

Lani Guinier on Meritocracy


In this inteview by Rebecca Parrish, Prof. Lani Guinier of Harvard Law School talks about her new book (to be published in 2007) titled Meritocracy Inc.: How Wealth Became Merit, Class Became Race, and College Education Became a Gift from the Poor to the Rich. Here's the opening salvo:

Rebecca Parrish: What is meritocracy? What is the difference between the conventional understanding and the way you are using the term in Meritocracy, Inc.?

Lani Guinier: The conventional understanding of meritocracy is that it is a system for awarding or allocating scarce resources to those who most deserve them. The idea behind meritocracy is that people should achieve status or realize the promise of upward mobility based on their individual talent or individual effort. It is conceived as a repudiation of systems like aristocracy where individuals inherit their social status.

I am arguing that many of the criteria we associate with individual talent and effort do not measure the individual in isolation but rather parallel the phenomena associated with aristocracy; what we're calling individual talent is actually a function of that individual's social position or opportunities gained by virtue of family and ancestry. So, although the system we call "meritocracy" is presumed to be more democratic and egalitarian than aristocracy, it is in fact reproducing that which it was intended to dislodge.

Michael Young, a British sociologist, created the term in 1958 when he wrote a science fiction novel called The Rise of Meritocracy. The book was a satire in which he depicted a society where people in power could legitimate their status using "merit" as the justificatory terminology and in which others could be determined not simply to have been poor or left out but to be deservingly disenfranchised.

Here are two   profiles of Prof. Guinier. The Wikipedia entry is here. An incomplete list of her publications can be found here.

Amartya Sen: Merit and the Good Society


The idea of meritocracy may have many virtues, but clarity is not one of them. The lack of clarity may relate to the fact, as I shall presently argue, that the concept of "merit" is deeply contingent on our views of a good society. Indeed, the notion of merit is fundamentally derivative, and thus cannot but be qualified and contingent. There is some elementary tension between (1) the inclination to see merit in fixed and absolute terms, and (2) the ultimately instrumental character of merit--its dependence on the concept of "the good" in the relevant society.

This basic contrast is made more intense by the tendency, in practice, to characterize "merit" in inflexible forms reflecting values and priorities of the past, often in sharp conflict with conceptions that would be needed for seeing merit in the context of contemporary objectives and concerns. Some of the major difficulties with "meritocracy" arise, I would argue, from this internal conflict within the concept of "merit" itself.

From Amartya Sen's paper on Merit and Justice, published in Meritocracy and Economic Inequality, edited by Kenneth Arrow, Samuel Bowles, and Steven Durlauf (Princeton University Press, 1999). [Thanks to Pradeepkumar for the pointer].

Here's the central thesis:

[The] practice of rewarding good (or right) deeds for their incentive effects cannot but be an integral part of any well-functioning society. No matter what we think of the demands of "meritocracy" as it is usually defined, we can scarcely dispense with incentive systems altogether. The art of developing an incentive system lies in delineating the content of merit in such a way that it helps to generate valued consequences. [...]

The derivative character of merit leads us to the central question as to what the "valued consequences" are and how the success and failure of a society are to be judged. Once an instrumental view of merit is accepted, there is no escape from the contingent nature of its content, related to the characterization of a good--or an acceptable--society and the criteria in terms of which assessments are to be made.

Towards the end of the paper, Sen gets to what he calls "substantial departures" from this view of 'merit', and they are quite interesting:

  1. Personification and genetics: In the incentive approach to merit, it is characteristic of actions, not of people as such. But conventional notions of "meritocracy" often attach the label of merit to people rather than actions. A person with standardly recognized "talents" (even something as nebulous as "intelligence") can, then, be seen as a meritorious person even if he or she were not to use the "talents" to perform acts with good consequences or laudable propriety. This "personal quality" of merits sometimes gets invoked even in a largely incentive-oriented system of economic reasoning, with which the "personal quality" view is basically in conflict. [...]
  2. Deserts and entitlement: An incentive argument is entirely "instrumental" and does not lead to any notion of intrinsic "desert." If paying a person more induces him or her to produce more desirable results, then an incentive argument may exist for that person's pay being greater. This is an instrumental and contingent justification (related to results)--it does not assert that the person intrinsically "deserves" to get more. To return to an illustration used earlier, an incentive argument may well exist even for paying a blackmailer some money to induce him or her to hand over some compromising material, but that incentive argument is not the same as accepting that the blackmailer "deserves" to get that money because of the blackmailer's intrinsic virtue.

    In a meritocratic system, however, this distinction gets blurred, and the established and fixed nature of the system of rewards may generate the implicit--sometimes even explicit--belief that the rewards are "owed" by the society to the meritorious persons. [...]
  3. Distribution independence: A system of rewarding of merits may well generate inequalities of well-being and of other advantages. But, as was argued earlier, much would depend on the nature of the consequences that are sought, on the basis of which merits are to be characterized. If the results desired have a strong distributive component, with a preference for equality, then in assessing merits (through judging the generated results, including its distributive aspects), concerns about distribution and inequality would enter the evaluation. [...]

I have posted this link over at How the Other Half Lives. Comments are welcome there.

Varavara Rao: "You are lucky, you are meritorious"


Via Amit Kumar Singh (see his comment on this post), we have the link to Varavara Rao's poem titled Déjà vu from 1990. Here are a few stanzas from near the end of this poem:

Lucky
The corpse of your merit
Parades through the main streets
Has its funeral in `chourastas�
Amidst chanting of holy `mantras�

But Merit has no death
So
You creatively conduct symbolic procession
And enact the mourning `prahasan�
In us
To die or to be killed
There is no merit

We die
With hunger, or disease,
Doing hard labor, or committing crime,
In lock up or encounter
(Meritorious will not agree inequality is violence)

We will be thrown
By a roadside;
In a filthy pit;
On a dust heap;
In a dark forest

We will turn ash
Without a trace
We will `miss�
From a hill or a hole

Our births and deaths
Except for census statistics,
What use they have
For the national progress?

We take birth
And perish in death
In and due to
Miserable poverty
You assume the `Avatar�
When Dharma is in danger
And renounce the role
After completing the job
You are the `sutradhar�

You are lucky
You are meritorious.

Thursday, June 15, 2006

News from Harvard


There is quite a bit this week.

First, we have Larry Summers' last Commencement Address as Harvard's President:

Our world is bursting with knowledge - but desperately in need of wisdom. Now, when sound bites are getting shorter, when instant messages crowd out essays, and when individual lives grow more frenzied, college graduates capable of deep reflection are what our world needs.

For all these reasons I believed - and I believe even more strongly today - in the unique and irreplaceable mission of universities.

Universities are where the wisdom we cannot afford to lose is preserved from generation to generation. Among all human institutions, universities can look beyond present norms to future possibilities, can look through current considerations to emergent opportunities.

And among universities, Harvard stands out. With its great tradition, its iconic reputation, its remarkable network of 300,000 alumni, its unmatched capacity to attract brilliant students and faculty, its scope for physical expansion in Allston and its formidable financial resources, Harvard has never had as much potential as it does now. Thanks to your generosity and the endowment's strong performance, our resources have increased in just the last three years by nearly seven billion dollars. This is more than the total endowment of all but four other universities in the world.

And yet, great and proud institutions, like great and proud nations at their peak, must surmount a very real risk: that the very strength of their traditions will lead to caution, to an inward focus on prerogative and to a complacency that lets the world pass them by.

And so I say to you that our University today is at an inflection point in its history. At such a moment, there is temptation to elevate comfort and consensus over progress and clear direction, but this would be a mistake. The University's matchless resources - human, physical, financial - demand that we seize this moment with vision and boldness. To do otherwise would be a lost opportunity, not only for Harvard but also for humanity. We can spur great deeds that history will mark decades and even centuries from now. If Harvard can find the courage to change itself, it can change the world.

This week's edition of the Harvard Crimson has all kinds of interesting stuff on Commencement'06. Do take a look. Its report on the Summers speech is here; its editorial about Summers' legacy is here.

The Crimson also has special sections devoted to the Class of '56 and the Class of '81 which feature profiles of some of the graduates from these classes. At least two names were familiar to me: Kenneth G. Wilson (Nobel laureate in Physics, 1981) and Susan Faludi (Pulitzer Prize winning journalist and feminist).

Wednesday, June 14, 2006

Google presents


The complete plays of Shakespeare.

Link via Google Blog, which also provides a link to the blog of the Google Book Search team, whose post on Shakespeare plays is titled:

No Holds Bard