Remember this post from five days ago? Today's NYTimes reports that Dr. Peter Nanos has announced that he is stepping down. Visit the blog that did a lot towards getting him out.
Saturday, May 07, 2005
Friday, May 06, 2005
Hi-fi(nance) women
The much reviled Economic Times did a story today on women who have made it big in the field of finance. If the number of such high-flying women is small, they are role models and change catalysts; if their number is large, such concepts as role models are not needed. I hope the women covered in this story represent a situation in the latter category. I know for a fact that Indian academia still has a long way to go to make role models irrelevant -- particularly in the sciences (except perhaps biology and medicine).
Here's an extract from yesterday's NYTimes story about Dr. Susan Hockfield, the MIT President-elect:
One of her first major public acts as president was to respond to a suggestion, by Harvard's president, Dr. Lawrence H. Summers, that one reason for the relative dearth of women at the upper ranks of science might be an innate lesser ability.
"Marie Curie exploded that myth," Dr. Hockfield and two other university presidents, Dr. Shirley M. Tilghman of Princeton and Dr. John L. Hennessy of Stanford, wrote in an essay that appeared on the op-ed page of The Boston Globe. But women need "teachers who believe in them," they went on, and low expectations of women "can be as destructive as overt discrimination."
One thing that came through loud and clear from the ET story is the great stature enjoyed by ICICI Bank for its ability to nurture women executives. This company has Lalita Gupte, Kalpana Morparia, Chanda Kochhar and Renuka Ramnath occupying key -- and high -- positions.
All I can say is, "Way to go!"
Update: The ET story presents other information that are also a cause for celebration: diversity. In the educational backgrounds of these five high-achieving women, you find a very interesting diversity beyond the usual (and boring!) IITs or IIM-A,B and C:
- Nithya Easwaran: VJTI (Electronics) and IIM-Lucknow.
- Sutapa Banerjee: Econ from Presidency (Kolkata?) and XLRI.
- Manisha Girtra: St. Stephen's and Delhi School of Economics
- Ashu Suyash: Commerce degree from Bombay Univ. and CA
- and, finally, Natasha Patel, who has a Ph.D. in French literature from none other than the Sorbonne!
Interlinking of rivers
Here are two informative pieces from India Together about the Interlinking of Rivers (ILR) project. The second piece, which contains the text of a recent speech by Jairam Ramesh in the Rajya Sabha, sums up the issue nicely:
... I do believe that in today's day and age, with today's media, with today's civil society, it is not possible for us to overlook the ecological and human population resettlement consequences of such a massive scheme. Yesterday, you would have seen in the newspapers, Sir, that there is a new study that has come out, that has called into question the utility of Bhakhra Nangal Dam. Sir, even today's day and age, I do not think that we can rush into this project oblivious of the consequences of resettlement of millions of people, and let us also face it, Sir, India's track record in resettlement and rehabilitation has been pathetic, has been poor. This is a blot on our collective conscience.
The ILR proposal is not a new one; however, nobody paid any attention to it until recently for a good reason: its huge cost -- financial, environmental and human. There is now a heightened interest in ILR because of certain pronouncements by the Supreme Court and the zeal with which our President, Dr. Abdul Kalam, has been pushing the idea. See a paraphrase of Dr. Kalam's 9th question in this article, and the reply provided by some concerned citizens; see also this excellent op-ed by one of these concerned citizens, Ramaswamy Iyer, in the Hindu dated 14 December 2003.
Bottomline: while some parts of the proposal might make sense, the project as a whole is not at all a good idea. Sorry, Sunil, it will not "in one single master-stroke solve all of India's water problems".
Update: India Together has an article about recent research on the Bhakra dam that Jairam Ramesh talked about in his speech.
Sweet irony
In this interesting post, Ravikiran Rao takes Dilip D'Souza to task for being sloppy with logic in his Rediff piece. I am not sure that the allegation sticks. Here's why.
The usual goal of a country's economic management advocated by almost everyone (including libertarians) is growth in GDP; in other words, a bigger pie. Usually, one ignores how the pie is divided. Suppose, for a moment, you start with a different primary goal for economic policies: to reduce poverty (with enhanced GDP as a secondary goal), and if what you see indicates that poverty doesn't seem to have decreased (or, it seems to have increased; "seems" is the key word here ;-) after traveling 15 years down the garden path, then you are apt to question the wisdom of the reforms as they are being pursued. I believe this is what Dilip has done:
There's no doubt in my mind: reforms must happen. But 15 years after the process began, I can't help feeling that something is wrong about the way we are pursuing them. For I am yet to see the one effect they must have, first and above all: a visible lessening in the level of Indian poverty. Fewer poor Indians around us. I can't see that.
So, in spite of Dilip's support for reforms (after all, he is not questioning them; he is only wondering about better ways of doing them), Ravikiran gives him a gratuitous remedial lesson in how to talk about "reforms and the poor"!
In any case, one could argue that Dilip has achieved something fundamentally very significant with far-reaching consequences: He has made card-carrying libertarians acknowledge -- and talk about -- certain economic policies and defend them on their impact on the poor.
Congratulations, Dilip!
Thursday, May 05, 2005
Sex and its analogues
Here are two interesting analogies, both involving sex :
- Documentation [in computer programs] is a lot like sex. When it is good, it is really good; when it is bad, it is better than nothing.
(paraphrase of a fortune cookie from my linux machine ...) - Physics is like sex. Sure, it may give some practical results, but that's not why we do it.
(Richard P. Feynman)
VQube, the VoIP product from IISc!
Three of my colleagues at IISc, Professors K.V.S. Hari, T.V. Sreenivas and H. S. Jamadagni run their first -- and our Institute's third -- entrepreneurial venture: Esqube Communication Solutions. Their first software product, named VQube, after being beta-tested in the US and Japan, is now ready and available for download (free, trial version). Hari and I were talking about Esqube this afternoon, and here is what he told me about their new baby:
VQube allows you to use your Windows-based PC -- which should have a microphone, speakers, sound card and an internet connection -- to make telephone calls through the internet. The only restriction is that the other person should also have a PC with all these features, including VQube. It is optimized for use even on a dial-up connection; with a higher-bandwidth (broadband, for example) internet link, it is even better. It does everything that its its more established competitor (that shall not be named here!) does, and then some more!
VQube's USPs are: (a) it works even with the lowly dial-up connection, and (b) it, unlike its competitor, is a strictly peer-to-peer product.
In sum -- and in semi-geek language -- it is a peer-to-peer and low-bandwidth-friendly internet telephony product!
I would really like to give a glowing account of how VQube has really changed (transformed!) my telephony experience. The reason I cannot is that I am a linux-only person, and VQube is a Windows-only software! Needless to say, I am looking forward to VQube-LX ...
See the VQube website for more details on its capabilities that include, for example, conference calls. If you want more info, you might want to look at this Businessworld story. There are at least two bloggers who have written about VQube.
I urge you to check out VQube, and to spread the word. More importantly, if you have any suggestions for the product, do please get in touch with VQube's developers. These academics, strangely enough, are hungry for feedback!
Meanwhile, on the education front ...
Via Kama: This BBC report in pictures about Barefoot College in rural Rajastan is truly inspiring.
This one, on the other hand, is not: UNESCO's Global Education Digest has some sobering information on the current state of education and schooling in India:
The gross enrolment ratio, which measures the number of students at a given level as a percentage of the total population in the relevant age group, stands at 71% at the lower secondary level and 39% at the higher secondary level in India.
Assuming a figure of about 20 million as the population of children at any age, this statistic tells us that only 8 million of them are enrolled in school at the higher secondary level. In an op-ed in the Hindu published a while ago, Prof. Philip Altbach of Boston College said, "India educates approximately 10 per cent of its young people in higher education".
Charukesi has a post on NGOs that are into improving literacy, such as the India Literacy Project and Asha.
Cornelia Dean has a report on Dr. Susan Hockfield, a biologist about to take over as the President of MIT, "one of the world's leading citadels of physics, electrical engineering and other hard sciences", and the most macho of institutions of higher education. (Do catch the report in the next few days before NYTimes hides it behind its pay-wall). Prof. Hockfield, together with the Presidents of Princeton and Stanford, wrote a Boston Globe op-ed titled "Women and science: the real issue" in response to certain remarks on this issue by Larry Summers, the President of Harvard. We have already noted the blogosphere's reactions here and here.
Finally, let me move from education to academia-at-large with some really good news. The NYTimes reports that the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) has elected 19 women, the highest number ever, among its 72 new members. You can get the list here. The Academy also elected 18 foreign associates from 14 countries "in recognition of their distinguished and continuing achievements in original research", and India's very own Dr. R. A. Mashelkar, "CEO" of the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research is among them.
Wednesday, May 04, 2005
Neat trick
Via Tyler Cowen at Marginal Revolution:
If you don't like getting your paper rejected before it even reaches peer review, ask David Egilman how to get around the process: In what may be an unprecedented move, when the Brown University researcher's paper was recently rejected from an occupational medicine journal, he simply bought two pages of ad space and printed the entire article in the same journal.
Clever, ..., very, very clever!
Truly priceless
Ravi Balakrishnan did a recent story in the Economic Times on the brand equity of "spiritual" gurus all across the globe. In a sidebar, he describes how savvy they are in marketing themselves; did you know, for example, that "Mata Amritanandamayi’s stores stock everything from DVDs and VHS tapes, priced between $15 and $27, to books, incense sticks and even unlikely items like ‘essential oil’ at $10, and Amma shower gel and body lotion at $9 each"?
But what really takes the cake is this wonderful gem that appears in the interview of Sri Sri Ravishankar in a second sidebar. The question is about how vital the celebrities such as Vijay Mallya are to his organization, and Sri Sri's answer is [emphasis added by me]:
Art of Living is like an ocean where everybody is welcome. We don’t excommunicate somebody just because they are rich and famous.
Priceless, isn't it?
IITs in the news (again...)
Update (27.8.2005): Urmi Goswami reports in to-day's Economic Times that the JEE could be in a simpler format from the academic year 2006-07 itself.
I find it difficult to understand why people should get upset about IIT-JEE syllabus being made to conform to that of the +2 (higher secondary education) across all the education boards in India. Unlike Primary Red at Secular-Right and Amit Varma at India Uncut, I welcome it, simply because it levels the playing field -- only slightly, though -- for everyone. In the present system, students of ISC and CBSE schools have an inherent advantage simply because their syllabi are the closest approximation to that of JEE than the syllabus of any other board.
Why do I doubt that this proposed move make any difference? Simply because the ISC and CBSE students with a mastery over advanced topics will continue to enjoy an advantage over their lesser cousins. Clearly, coaching classes with an estimated total business of about 30 billion (3000 crore) rupees, are not in any danger of having to close down because of lack of students. The likely positive effect is essentially psychological: scores of students who do not make the cut can now leave the exam hall with the satisfaction of having tried at least a few questions successfully.
Finally, when it comes to rhetoric and choice of words, don't you think the secular right is right up their with the rabid right in its celebration of testosterone? Sissification? Yikes!
On the other hand, the other proposed move is to open up IITs and IIMs to Pakistani students, who will also be selected through JEE or CAT. Nitin, whose blog was blocked by a country that he visited recently, has weighed in against this proposal, and so has Primary Red. As of now, I have nothing against it, except to wonder why we should restrict it only to Pakistan. On a practical level, though, I think this proposal is dead on arrival; the IIT faculty are unlikely to accept it.
Tuesday, May 03, 2005
This and that ...
Via the excellent kitabkhana : Ram Guha's article in the Telegraph, in which he draws (once again) a moral equivalent between the left and the right. A while ago, he tried this stupid stunt -- and it is a stupid stunt, because he claims to be left of center -- when he called the noted activist Arundhati Roy the Arun Shourie of the left! After all the hard-hitting flak he received for that barb, including a serious dressing down by Ms. Roy herself, I thought he would refrain from such sound bites. Well, I guess I am wrong. See also Anand's post for another example of Ram's left-baiting.
Neha Viswanathan has a post about Motorcycle diaries:
I am a hardcore capitalist, and I have never understood why anyone could be so blinded by Communist ideal, and yet, I understand idealism and how consuming it can be. Idealism is a trait one picks up in early years, and holds on to. Because the only truth worth its salt is the one ridden with ambiguity.
Ravikiran Rao and Gargi describe two different ways in which the world will end. On the other hand, S.K. has a different catastrophe in mind: the declining sex ratio in India. Apparently, it has already started wreaking havoc in the Tamil Brahmin (Tam-Bram, as he calls it) community :
When the eminently eligible one seeks a suitable girl, using the algorithm of horoscopes (horror-scopes to many!), through matrimony dot coms, swayamvaras as well as the old faithful- newspaper classifieds, their parents find the tables squarely turned! Yes, it is no longer the boys’ hegemony. “Brides wanted” outnumber the “Bridegrooms wanted” by 3 to 2. The girls’ photographs are hard-to-get commodity (you need a password to steal a look at the nubile young things). The fairer sex has turned finicky and fastidious, thanks to the BPO’s and consequent financial emancipation. And the pre-requisite for an alliance is an upfront assurance on the girl’s career ambitions and premarital fiscal commitments.
Apropos of nothing, let me just end this post with a nice little gem that I found via Evelyn Rodrguez :
Always we hope someone else has the answer.
Some other place will be better,
some other time it will all turn out.
This is it.
No one else has the answer.
No other place will be better,
and it has already turned out. -- Lao Tzu.
That's all, folks!
Liberalization and poverty
First, Dilip D'Souza started it with an article at Rediff about liberalization's inability to make a dent on poverty in India:
There's no doubt in my mind: reforms must happen. But 15 years after the process began, I can't help feeling that something is wrong about the way we are pursuing them. For I am yet to see the one effect they must have, first and above all: a visible lessening in the level of Indian poverty. Fewer poor Indians around us. I can't see that.
Dilip's post attracted a thuggish treatment at the hands of Sandeep and his commenters (except uspeed ;-). I would never have suspected that Sandeep's rants could actually inspire someone to take up his cause, but this one did: Yazad Jal did a nice piece rebutting Dilip's arguments, and got it published by Rediff (it appears to be his first "publication". Congratulations, Yazad!):
So how have so many poor people got themselves the money for shoes, transport, private education, fridges, television, coolers and cell phones? Maybe those figures have some answers after all. They're worth a brief look. India's GDP per capita in 1990, before liberalisation, was $1,300. Today it's $2,830, more than double. It's increased at around 5.33 per cent per year [on a PPP basis].
Yazad posted on his blog about his Rediff piece, and guess what? Dilip made a guest appearance in the comments section! The result? A very nice, civilized debate among the commenters, Dilip and Yazad.
Folks, this is the very best of the entire enterprise of blogging. Enjoy it before Sandeep and his fellow travellers spoil it!Monday, May 02, 2005
Richard Dawkins rocks
This interview of Richard Dawkins is an absolute gem. Salon will let you read it for free if you are willing to see three screenfuls of a stupid ad. Trust me, the interview is worth more than three screenfuls of junk!
Dawkins says, "A delusion is something that people believe in despite a total lack of evidence. Religion is scarcely distinguishable from childhood delusions like the 'imaginary friend' and the bogeyman under the bed. [...] The word "delusion" also carries negative connotations, and religion has plenty of those". When asked what those negative connotations were, he replied :
A delusion that encourages belief where there is no evidence is asking for trouble. Disagreements between incompatible beliefs cannot be settled by reasoned argument because reasoned argument is drummed out of those trained in religion from the cradle. Instead, disagreements are settled by other means which, in extreme cases, inevitably become violent. Scientists disagree among themselves but they never fight over their disagreements. They argue about evidence or go out and seek new evidence. Much the same is true of philosophers, historians and literary critics.
But you don't do that if you just know your holy book is the God-written truth and the other guy knows that his incompatible scripture is too. People brought up to believe in faith and private revelation cannot be persuaded by evidence to change their minds. No wonder religious zealots throughout history have resorted to torture and execution, to crusades and jihads, to holy wars and purges and pogroms, to the Inquisition and the burning of witches.
What does he say about doing science?
[T]he scientific worldview is a poetic worldview, it is almost a transcendental worldview. We are amazingly privileged to be born at all and to be granted a few decades -- before we die forever -- in which we can understand, appreciate and enjoy the universe.
Also read the discussion at the end of P.Z. Myers' post about the Salon interview.
Ragging
Jaya Jha confesses to "[h]aving been a pretty strong "anti-ragging" person myself". Through her, I found a link to this very thoughtful piece by Sujit Saraf, in which he talks about his experiences with ragging at IIT-D, discusses the seniors' rationalizations of ragging, and presents cogent arguments (not that one needs any) for why it is an awful practice. A key quote:
[The seniors] had endured similar humiliation in their time. Their seniority in the hostel gave them, for the first time in their lives, power over other human beings – power to command fear, subjugate and humiliate.
Stop this barbaric practice now!
Bloggers force a regime change ?
Here is another interesting piece of the blog puzzle. The New York Times reports (catch it before it goes behind NYTimes' awful pay-per-view firewall) that "a blog rebellion among scientists and engineers at Los Alamos [National Laboratory], the federal government's premier nuclear weapons laboratory, is threatening to end the tenure of its director, G. Peter Nanos". Here is an extract:
Many bloggers criticize his decision to shut down most of the laboratory in July, when he cited "egregious" safety and security violations after two computer disks with secret information were reported missing and an intern working with a laser suffered an eye injury. The security alarm turned out to be a clerical error - the disks, in fact, never existed. Still, Dr. Nanos kept many laboratory areas closed for nearly seven months, until late January."
Read the blog: LANL - The real story, that has moved Jeff Jarvis (who was quoted by the NYTimes story), to say this in his blog:
I was called and quoted on it, saying that this isn't really about blogs but about citizens empowered. Blogs happen to be the catalyst. The ethic of transparency is sweeping the land.