Monday, May 29, 2006

Andre Beteille and Pratap Bhanu Mehta


Some quick links.

* * *

You all know that the distinguished sociologist Andre Beteille resigned from the National Knowledge Commission recently. Pratap Bhanu Mehta is the other Commissioner to resign from NKC. Their resignation letters were made public, and you can read them both here.

Yogendra Yadav, one of the authors of a fine-tuned plan of affirmative action (which I linked to here), wrote a letter addressing some of the issues raised by Mehta, who wrote a reply -- both appeared in the Indian Express [links via Aswin].

Now, Andre Beteille opens up and reveals some of his concerns about Indian universities in this ToI op-ed.

Science and marriage


Several years ago, Satoshi Kanazawa, then a psychologist at the University of Canterbury in Christchurch, New Zealand, analyzed a biographical database of 280 great scientists--mathematicians, physicists, chemists, and biologists. When he calculated the age of each scientist at the peak of his career--the sample was predominantly male--Kanazawa noted an interesting trend. After a crest during the third decade of life, scientific productivity--as evidenced by major discoveries and publications--fell off dramatically with age. When he looked at the marital history of the sample, he found that the decline in productivity was less severe among men who had never been married. As a group, unmarried scientists continued to achieve well into their late 50s, and their rates of decline were slower. [...]

Marriage has also been shown to have an adverse impact on the careers of female scientists. Data from the National Science Foundation show that female, doctoral-level scientists, and engineers are less likely to be married than are their male counterparts (66% versus 83%). Among those married, however, women are more likely to confront problems accommodating a two-career marriage--one reason being that they are twice as likely as men to have a spouse who works full-time. Add children to the mix, and the problem is compounded. Research by Kimberlee Shauman, an assistant professor of sociology at the University of California, Davis, found that time off for birth and child rearing poses a significant, often irreversible, impediment to a woman’s career.

That's what the data say. Now, what does one make of this evolutionary psychological explanation of the data:

Kanazawa's perhaps controversial perspective is that of an evolutionary psychologist. "Men conduct scientific research (or do anything else) in order to attract women and get married (albeit unconsciously)," he says. "What’s the point of doing science (or anything else) if one is already married? Marriage (or, more accurately reproductive success, which men can usually attain only through marriage) is the goal; science or anything else men do is but a means. From my perspective, scientists are no different than anybody else; evolutionary psychology applies to all humans equally," he adds.

Hmmm ...

* * *

Thanks to this recently married scientist and blogger for the pointer.

Calvin and Hobbes


Enjoy.

The original link doesn't work any more. Sigh!

Mother's milk


Check out these two wonderful posts over at Pharyngula: Mother's milk, and Breast beginnings. The latter explains a (currently speculative) theory about the evolution of breasts.

Of hemlines and bra sizes


The Glossary page (on the website of a user-friendly investment company) has an entry on the Hemline Theory (Carefully Capitalized, of course):

Hemline Theory: Capricious idea that stock prices move in the same direction as women's dress hemlines. Short dresses and skirts are considered bullish signs that stock prices will rise. Longer dresses and skirts are considered bearish signs that stock prices will decline. Notwithstanding that it is occasionally correct, the hemline theory has endured more as wishful thinking than serious market analysis.

Last week, I encountered, in Outlook Business (sorry, it has no web presence), the Bra Size Theory of Economic Development:

Here's a biological proof of China's prosperity. Women there are growing larger. The country's bra makers have started making larger cup sizes since last year, with some even creating sub-brands specializing in large sizes. Demand for small bras has fallen so much that Hong Kong-based Embry Group has halted production of smallest sizes for some of its product lines. ... The Beijing Institute of Clothing Technology has released a report saying the average chest circumference of Chinese women has hit 83.53 cm, up nearly 1 cm from the early 1990s. Call it the fruit of reforms; the growth trend is credited to women eating more nutritiously and taking part in more sports. Obviously, the trickle-down hasn't reached rural China yet. ...

A quick search for Beijing Institute of Clothing Technology revealed that it is seeking talent.

Here's a BBC report on the BICT report.

Sunday, May 28, 2006

Teen repellent - Part Deux


After the original use of high frequency sound waves, it is time for revenge.

The debate continues ...


First, some news. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh struck just the right note when he met the striking medicos two days ago:

Dr. Singh told a delegation of students that he foresaw a big expansion in the capacities of the higher education system, resulting in huge educational opportunities for all classes and categories. Hence, they need not worry about shrinking educational opportunities ...

The medicos have decided to continue with their strike. While I don't support their agitation, I am with them on one of their demands: "a judicial commission to review the reservation policy".

Clearly, the debate is not over; let me just link to some new and noteworthy views from the past day or two.

First, we have Swaminathan S. Anklesaria Aiyar, with his weekly column Swaminomics in ToI.

The canteen boy who brings me tea may be more intelligent than me, and so too may be the man shining shoes on the roadside. But they were born in the wrong family, and never had access to good education or economic opportunities. So they remain on the fringes of society.

Meanwhile, lesser beings like me dominate society, on the spurious claim that we are the most meritorious. What gall! We got good marks because we had the most educated parents, the best books, and went to the best schools and colleges.

But others far more meritorious are rotting without education or opportunity in the slums and villages of India. In a fair and just society, the top two million or so positions would be occupied by people with an IQ of over 135. Lesser folk like me (and most striking doctors) would be just clerks or labourers.

He also goes on to the question of how to improve the reach and quality of our primary education.

We need to experiment with new, fairer systems. Let me suggest one. The government spends Rs 110,000 crore a year on education. Let Rs 10,000 crore of this be channelled through business federations like the CII and Ficci to run quality schools with 80% reservation for lower castes and tribals.

Technical assistance can come from Delhi Public School, which has already created a chain of quality schools in India and abroad.

Within five years, let us create two quality schools in every district headquarters. In the next five years, let us cover every tehsil headquarters, and give scholarships to needy students for school for college.

Next, we have Prof. N.S. Ramaswamy, former Director of IIM-B, who suggests that we make better use of our investment in education.

Without investing government funds, it is possible to double or even treble the capacity of universities, IITs, IIMs and similar institutions.

These institutions work only for 180 to 200 days a year. It is possible to stretch them up to 300 days or more. Classes in India start only after 9 a.m. or even later. Even in cold countries, classes start at 6 a.m. and go on till 10 p.m. It is possible to have two shifts in HES, thus expanding the capacity with the same physical infrastructure.

To compensate for these fine attempts to take things forward (with some new ideas towards solving problems), we have an utterly vacuous article in the Hindu's Sunday Magazine. After summarizing the pro-quota and anti-quota positions, the author, Akhila Sivadas, has the gall to say this:

The biggest casualty has been timely and effective debate and discourse. ... [A] valuable opportunity to revisit and engage in a wider debate ... has been lost.

Has Sivadas been sleeping through all the 'debate and discourse' going on all over the place? Is she not aware of well-argued articles by people like Purushottam Agrawal, and Yogendra Yadav and Satish Deshpande, and by Pratap Bhanu Mehta before his resignation? If they don't constitute 'a wider debate', what will?

Finally, a link from the blogosphere: Abhinav grapples with various questions about reservation in the IITs on his brand new blog All about IIT. He admits that he doesn't have all the answers yet, but he is asking some right questions. While on IITs, the Hindu reported today that 125 IIT-K professors have written to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh urging him not to implement quotas: "in the eventuality, [they] have threatened to resign en masse."

CBSE Results: Girls have done better


The results of Classes X and XII exams of the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) are out. Here are the links for the reports on Class XII and Class X results.

In both the exams, overall, girls have done better than the boys. The difference is smaller for Class X (77.7 for girls compared to 76.77 for boys and 77.16 overall) than for Class XII ((84.4 for girls compared to 75.93 for boys and 79.55 overall). This is what the Chairman of CBSE had to say:

"Unlike the Class XII examinations in which the gap between the girls and the boys was substantial, in the Class X examinations there was a less than one percentage point difference between them. This reinforces our theory that up to this level, girls and boys are almost the same, but the difference sets in after they are 16 years and above," CBSE Chairman Ashok Ganguly told a press conference ... [Link]

"The trend of girls doing better than boys started in 1991. We would like to do an analysis of why girls are doing better than boys to understand this trend. However, independent feedback that we have got so far shows that girls at this crucial juncture are more creative, innovative and focused than boys," said CBSE Chairman Ashok Ganguly at a press conference ... [Link].

The number of girls taking these exams is (slightly) lower, as can be seen from the fact that the overall pass percentage is (slightly) closer to the boys' than the girls'.

Not only have the girls done well overall (in terms of pass percentage), they have also done quite well in the 'elite' (with a score of over 90 percent) and 'super-elite' (over 95 percent) categories in the Class X exams:

While they might have done better than boys in the "elite" category of students getting 90 per cent or above, boys seem to have taken the lead as 10,617 of them scored over 90 per cent, compared to 10,385 girls. [...]

A total of 1,677 children in the country have scored over 95 per cent marks this year. There are 888 girls and 789 boys who made their mark in this "super-elite" category. [Link]

For class XII, however, this boys-vs-girls break-up among the '90+ percent' students is not given in any of the reports I checked. The CBSE website is of no help, either.

A couple of weeks ago, the ICSE and ISC exam results were also announced; once again, girls did better (overall) than boys. I looked for info on the boys-vs-girls break up among the toppers in these exams, but couldn't find any.

Any pointers would be appreciated. Thanks in advance.

Bangalore University


It has been more than two months since we had a look at the Bangalore University. The new Vice-Chancellor has been chosen: Prof. H.A. Ranganath, formerly with the Zoology Department at the University of Mysore, now has this job.

Prof. Ranganath has a lot on his hands. I strongly feel he should put an end to this silly proposal I don't know if he wants to handle this new proposal to impose a dress code on its students, and to make the boys and girls sit in separate sections (within the same classroom). Does Bangalore University's Syndicate have Prof. D. Viswanathan (Vice-Chancellor of Chennai's Anna University, who has imposed similar rules in its colleges) as one of its members?

Saturday, May 27, 2006

An announcement in the public interest ...


No, I am not stopping my posts on reservation!

This is for users of contact lens who also use Bausch and Lomb's ReNu MoistureLoc brand of lens cleaner. This product has been withdrawn from the market all over the world (US, India).

So, if you are a user of this product, stop using it!

This message is brought to you by Dr. M. Padmamalini, an ophthalmologist who claims that many people in India are still unaware of the recall of the product. She wanted her blogger husband to spread the word.

Thank you for your patience. Regular programming on the hot topics of the day will resume soon.

How to create a Silicon Valley


Get nerds and VCs (who, by the way, are former nerds) to come and settle down, says Paul Graham. He gives you the algorithm for doing that.

I think you only need two kinds of people to create a technology hub: rich people and nerds. They're the limiting reagents in the reaction that produces startups, because they're the only ones present when startups get started. Everyone else will move.

Observation bears this out: within the US, towns have become startup hubs if and only if they have both rich people and nerds. Few startups happen in Miami, for example, because although it's full of rich people, it has few nerds. It's not the kind of place nerds like.

Whereas Pittsburgh has the opposite problem: plenty of nerds, but no rich people. The top US Computer Science departments are said to be MIT, Stanford, Berkeley, and Carnegie-Mellon. MIT yielded Route 128. Stanford and Berkeley yielded Silicon Valley. But Carnegie-Mellon? The record skips at that point. [...]

Ouch!

Have you heard about the AIIMS quota?


Me neither, until I read Mom Knows Everything:

The main grouse of AIIMS students - at the forefront of the stir against 27% reservation for OBCs - is that merit is being sacrificed at the altar of votebank politics. But they forget two things: 25% reservation that AIIMS graduates get in PG admission and the Supreme Court judgment of 2001 that declares the earlier system of 33% reservation for them bad in law.

Read the whole story, there is more there ;-). Like, how the AIIMS quota enabled an AIIMS student with a lower score than an SC student to get a 'better' specialization in the PG course ...

I just found it too juicy to pass up ...

Sujai Karampuri


Check out his five-part (so far ;-) series on reservations:   I,   II,   III,   IV,   and   V.

Update: Sujai is prolific! Here is the sixth in the series. And, here is the seventh.

Update 2: Sujai is on a roll! Here is the eighth post in the series.

Here is my favourite sentence from this series:

Unfortunately, most parents in India judge their kids performance ONLY by their scores.

Friday, May 26, 2006

Work


First, this:

What is the best thing about work?

Figuring out how the mind works.

Then, this:

Our nearest relatives, the chimpanzees, will engage in barter. Meat is a scarce and valuable commodity, and successful hunters will trade bits of their catch to earn favor with higher-ranked members of the troop, for grooming and even for sex--it really is the world's oldest profession.

Both excerpts are from this Forbes special on Work. The first is a quickie interview with Steven Pinker on his first job (Assistant Professor of Psychology at Harvard) and the second is a wonderful article by P.Z. Myers (of Pharyngula fame) titled Non-human work. The Forbes special has a whole bunch more than these two, of course.

* * *

While on work, do take a look at this column by Austan Goolsbee, discussing a curious link between your career earnings and the economic conditions in the year of your graduation (and joining the workforce) [via Alex Tabarrok].

Thursday, May 25, 2006

Voltaire


I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.
-- Voltaire


I support your right to be an asshole, but do not assume that you are entitled to my respect.
-- Aishwarya


The company that publishes this newspaper suffers, like other investors, when the value of its investments in the market erodes. ... But we uphold the right of the bear to do his job without the government coming down on him like a tonne of bricks.
-- Economic Times